WhyNot?
Can't work

Why can't we all just get along?

Asked 15d ago · Updated 15d ago

Assessment

This is a fundamental limitation rooted in human psychology and evolution. While humans are capable of extraordinary cooperation, we've also evolved psychological mechanisms that create in-group bias and competition over perceived limited resources. Research from sources like the Annual Reviews (2024) and PNAS (2011) shows that conflict arises from evolved tendencies toward tribal thinking, misperception of goal structures, and cultural reinforcement of competitive behaviors. Even when cooperation would benefit everyone, people often irrationally choose competition. The solution isn't eliminating these tendencies (which would require changing human nature) but creating better systems and emphasizing shared goals.

Arguments

✅ Why it could work

  • Humans have evolved to cooperate and form communities - we're naturally social beings who benefit from working together

  • Most people share common basic values like wanting safety, happiness, and well-being for themselves and their families

  • Global communication and travel have shown that people from different cultures can understand and connect with each other

❌ Why it can't work

  • Competition for limited resources (land, water, energy, jobs) creates inherent conflicts between groups

  • Deep ideological and religious differences create fundamentally incompatible worldviews that cannot be reconciled

  • Psychological tribalism and in-group/out-group bias are hardwired evolutionary traits that make conflict inevitable

What can be done & who's doing it

No concrete actions yet. Be the first to share what you're doing or want to do.

Conversations (1)